The City of Montreal has won

    Superior Court Judge Pepita G. Capriolo has handed down her decision in the $44 million case opposing Groupe Pacific, the owners of Meadowbrook, and the City of Montreal.

    The City of Montreal has won on all counts.

    Groupe Pacific alleged that the City had to all intents and purposes expropriated the land and had acted in bad faith in dealing with them. The promoter was asking $28.5 million for the disguised expropriation and further added $10.4 million for the loss of housing unit sales and a further $5.045 million for the loss of lot sales. Groupe Pacific had originally purchased the land for $3 million in 2006.

    In her decision, the judge said the promoter did not manage to prove bad faith in the case of the City.  She also dismissed any damages: the promoter was requesting damages for both the loss of housing unit and lot sales.

    Les Amis du Parc Meadowbrook is very pleased with the outcome of this case and will continue its campaign to make Meadowbrook an urban nature park accessible to all.

    See, Pimento Report #124, “Meadowbrook — A Park for All”. Go to 7 minutes, 40 seconds in the timeline to view Campbell Stuart’s presentation on the history of the struggle to preserve Meadowbrook and an interview with Campbell about the significance of this lawsuit. (In English only.)

    See also:

    Meadowbrook Brief Says l’Anse-à-l’Orme Must Be Preserved

    Les Amis du parc Meadowbrook told a recent hearing that the l’Anse-à-l’Orme green space in western Pierrefonds must be protected from development. The brief, presented by Campbell Stuart on behalf of Les Amis, told the Office de consultation publique de Montréal (OCPM) hearing that l’Anse-à-l’Orme must be preserved and turned into a nature park, open and accessible to everyone.

    The OCPM hearings were considering a proposal to allow developers to build 5,500 houses on 185 hectares of wetlands, woods, fields and former farmland. The l’Anse-à-l’Orme area consists primarily of wet meadows, located on a floodplain, which are unsuitable for construction.

    The brief outlined three main reasons to reject the proposed development. First, the area should be preserved for its intrinsic environmental value to future generations. It is home to several threatened and endangered species, including the Least Bittern, Northern Map Turtle and Brown Snake, as well as other birds, reptiles, and mammals.

    The wetlands and small rivers of the area form a thriving and self-sustaining wilderness ecosystem in the heart of the West Island. Researchers at l’Université du Québec en Outaouais conducted an exhaustive study of the rich biodiversity of this area (“Évaluation écologique de l’Ouest du territoire de Pierrefonds-Roxboro”,

    Les Amis argued the proposed development should not go ahead for urban planning reasons. The project fails to meet Montreal’s own criteria for sustainable development since it does not protect natural areas, it promotes the use of automobiles and it does not revitalize existing neighbourhoods.

    The proposal should also be rejected for fiscal reasons, since taxpayers are being asked to subsidize speculative ventures for private profit. A study on the issue of taxpayer costs done by a researcher at l’Université du Québec à Montréal, (“Analyse des contraintes, coûts et impacts d’un éventuel projet immobilier dans le secteur Pierrefonds-Ouest / L’Anse à l’Orme“, demonstrated that building a new housing development in this area would require massive new infrastructure funded by taxpayers, with little chance of recouping those costs.

    The brief suggested that the mandate given to the OCPM threatens the consultative body’s independence and neutrality. The brochure for the hearings invites the public “to come validate and improve the vision” of the proposed development, while stating that the “OCPM was created specifically to ensure that certain public consultations in Montreal are led by a neutral and independent organization.”

    Saying that other areas of the city are more suitable for sustainable development, Les Amis’ brief recommended the City of Montreal and the Borough of Pierrefonds-Roxboro change the zoning of the area to recreational.

    “We also call on them to work with other levels of government to create a nature park, open and accessible to all and encompassing on the whole territory of the L’Anse-à-l’Orme Corridor. This natural space is just too precious to us and our descendants to allow it to be destroyed for private gain.”

    Several members of Les Amis de Meadowbrook also presented briefs as private citizens.

    Supplemental Brief on Rouge National Urban Park, Toronto

    Download (PDF, 252KB)

    Les Amis Keeping the Public Informed

    Les Amis du Parc Meadowbrook recently held the first of a series of information meetings to update the public on the current status of the green space at Meadowbrook. The meeting took place in Cote St. Luc, with similar events planned in Montreal West, NDG, Lachine and Westmount.

    Members of the audience signed a petition that calls on Mayor Denis Coderre to create a nature park, accessible to all, on the Meadowbrook site. There is a link to the petition at

    Speakers explained a proposal, sent to Montreal West, Lachine and NDG, to create infrastructure linked to a new bike/walking path to be built at the bottom of the Falaise St. Jacques as part of the Turcot project. Ideally, it would link to their communities and connect to Meadowbrook. Efforts continue to persuade the Quebec transport ministry to construct the dalle-parc pedestrian/bike bridge, shown in the original plans, over the Turcot, connecting NDG and the South-West borough.

    There was also discussion of the recent Montreal Green Charter event, held to mark the one-year anniversary of the adoption of the Charter for the Protection of Montreal’s Green Spaces and Natural Environments. This event drew about 60 people to hear panelists discuss issues related to the Green Charter, including urban sprawl, biodiversity, public transit and access to green spaces. The Charter was adopted at Forum Nature, Montreal’s first citizen conference on the protection of natural spaces, in April 2016.

    Participants attending this year’s Green Charter event gave the City of Montreal failing grades on environmental issues such as stopping urban sprawl, protecting green spaces and biodiversity, reducing car dependency, improving public transit and providing greater access to green spaces.

    To keep up regularly with the activities of Les Amis de Meadowbrook and to find out more about environmental issues in the Montreal area, see our Facebook page or sign up to receive our newsletter. To attend a regular monthly meeting or learn how you can help as a volunteer, email